LONDON — The Bank of England faces one of its most finely balanced decisions in years after the latest inflation figures showed consumer prices easing only marginally, leaving policymakers torn between supporting a fragile economy and keeping pressure on stubborn price growth.
Data released by the Office for National Statistics on Tuesday showed that annual consumer price inflation held at 3.8 percent in September, unchanged from August and still nearly double the central bank’s 2 percent target. Core inflation, which strips out volatile food and energy prices, eased slightly to 3.6 percent from 3.8 percent, but remained elevated by historical standards.
The figures complicate the outlook for the Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), which meets in early November to decide whether to cut interest rates from their current level of 4 percent. Markets had been pricing in a quarter‑point reduction, but the persistence of inflation has cast doubt on whether the committee will move so soon.
“The latest data leave the MPC in a very difficult position,” said Ruth Gregory, chief UK economist at Capital Economics. “Growth is weak, the labour market is softening, but inflation is still too high for comfort. A November cut is no longer a done deal.”
Inflation Stubbornly High
The inflation report underscored the stickiness of price pressures across the economy. While transport costs fell, driven by lower airfares and easing fuel prices, other categories continued to climb. Food inflation accelerated to 5.1 percent, the highest since early 2024, while restaurant and hotel prices also rose. Housing and utilities costs remained elevated, reflecting high energy bills and rents.
The persistence of inflation has frustrated policymakers who had hoped that a series of rate cuts earlier this year would bring price growth closer to target. Since June 2024, the Bank has lowered its benchmark rate from 5.25 percent to 4 percent, citing signs of slowing demand and easing supply bottlenecks. But the latest data suggest that underlying pressures remain.
Governor Andrew Bailey acknowledged the challenge in a speech last week, warning that “inflation is proving more persistent than we would like.” He added that while the Bank was prepared to cut rates further if the economy weakened, it would not do so at the expense of price stability.
For households, the stubborn inflation means continued pressure on living standards. Wages have risen, but not enough to fully offset higher prices, leaving many families struggling with the cost of essentials. Consumer confidence remains fragile, with surveys showing households cautious about spending.
Growth Weak, Labour Market Softening
At the same time, the broader economy shows signs of strain. GDP growth was flat in August, following a modest contraction in July, and business surveys point to sluggish activity in both manufacturing and services. The labour market, once a source of resilience, is beginning to soften, with unemployment edging up to 4.6 percent and vacancies declining.
The combination of weak growth and high inflation — a scenario economists call “stagflation lite” — leaves the Bank of England in a bind. Cutting rates could support demand and ease borrowing costs for households and businesses, but it risks reigniting inflation. Holding rates steady could keep inflation in check, but at the cost of further dampening growth.
“The MPC is walking a tightrope,” said Sanjay Raja, chief UK economist at Deutsche Bank. “They need to balance the risk of doing too little on inflation with the risk of doing too much on growth. It’s a very fine judgment.”
Financial markets reflect that uncertainty. Sterling rose modestly against the dollar after the inflation data, as traders scaled back bets on a November cut. Gilt yields also climbed, with the 10‑year yield rising to 4.1 percent, reflecting expectations that rates may stay higher for longer.
Political and Global Context
The Bank’s decision also carries political implications. Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s government, elected earlier this year, has pledged to prioritize economic stability and growth. Ministers have avoided pressuring the Bank directly, but they are acutely aware that high borrowing costs weigh on households and businesses. A rate cut would provide some relief, but if it reignites inflation, it could undermine the government’s credibility.
Globally, the Bank of England’s dilemma mirrors that of other central banks. The European Central Bank signaled last week that its easing cycle may be over after a series of cuts brought rates down to 2 percent. In the United States, the Federal Reserve has paused its own rate reductions, citing sticky inflation and financial stability concerns. The divergence in policy paths has implications for currency markets and capital flows, adding another layer of complexity for the Bank.
“The UK is not alone in facing this challenge,” said Karen Ward, chief market strategist at JPMorgan Asset Management. “Central banks everywhere are grappling with the same question: how to support growth without letting inflation get out of hand.”
The Road Ahead
With the November meeting approaching, attention will focus on upcoming data releases, including wage growth, retail sales, and business surveys. If those indicators show further weakness, the case for a rate cut could strengthen. But if inflation remains sticky, the Bank may opt to wait until December or early 2026.
For now, economists are divided. Some argue that the Bank should move quickly to support the economy, pointing to signs of a slowdown and the risk of recession. Others say patience is warranted, warning that premature easing could undo progress on inflation.
“The decision is on a knife edge,” said Gregory of Capital Economics. “It could go either way, and the data over the next two weeks will be crucial.”
For households and businesses, the uncertainty means continued volatility in borrowing costs and financial markets. Mortgage rates, which had fallen in anticipation of cuts, may remain elevated if the Bank holds steady. Businesses planning investments face uncertainty about the cost of capital.
Ultimately, the Bank’s decision will hinge on its assessment of the balance of risks. As Bailey put it last week: “We are determined to return inflation to target, but we must also ensure that monetary policy supports the economy. It is a delicate balance, and we will act in the best interests of the country.”
Conclusion: A Decision in the Balance
The latest inflation data leave the Bank of England facing one of its toughest calls in years. With price pressures still elevated and growth faltering, the case for a rate cut is finely balanced. The decision will have far‑reaching implications for households, businesses, and financial markets, shaping the trajectory of the UK economy as it heads into 2026.
For now, the message is clear: the path of interest rates is uncertain, and the outcome will depend on the data. As the November meeting approaches, all eyes will be on the Bank of England — and on whether it chooses to prioritize growth, inflation, or a precarious balance of both.
Reporting by Nick Ravenshade. Original reporting and analysis NENC Media Group.
Sources: Bank of England, Office for National Statistics Trading Economics, CNBC, The Independent.
Photo: Alicja Ziajowska / Unsplash
Comments ()